These yogurts deserve a spot in your fridge.
A photograph of 5 different dairy free yogurt alternatives
Credit: Ted + Chelsea Cavanaugh

Whether you add it to a smoothie, top it with granola or just enjoy on its own, yogurt is a healthy and delicious option. And now, creamy cultured dairy-free cups are filling up the yogurt aisle. To help you find the tastiest option, we tested 15 different plain varieties, and picked the best five. Read on to learn more about each yogurt and what to look for on a nutrition label.

Understanding a Yogurt Nutrition Label

The Sugar Situation

Some plain varieties of dairy-free yogurts have added sugar, anywhere from 1 to 9 grams. Look for ones with no more than 6 grams added sugar per serving (typically 5.3 oz., about ¾ cup).

Calorie Comparison

These yogurts provide anywhere from 70 to 170 calories per serving, so it pays to read the label. Oat-based ones tend to be on the low end, with higher-fat options like coconut-based yogurts at the higher end.

Pining for Protein

With less than 1 gram and up to 7 grams of protein per serving, none are equivalent to dairy-based yogurt (regular has about 9 grams protein per serving, while Greek has about 16 grams). Soy is the highest-protein option, at 7 grams per serving, but you can always up the protein by topping with nuts or seeds.

Calcium, Covered

Plain, regular and Greek dairy-based yogurts offer about 200-300mg calcium per serving and many plant-based yogurts are comparable. But unlike with cow's-milk versions, these are calcium-fortified. If you are looking for dairy-free yogurt to be a good source of calcium, opt for varieties that supply at 200 mg calcium (15% Daily Value).

5 Best Plant-Based Yogurts

Silk Dairy Free Soy Yogurt Plain
Credit: Sunbelt Natural

Silk Plain Soymilk Dairy-Free Yogurt Alternative

The highest-protein option on the list, this choice also has the most dairy-like flavor.

110 cal, 0.5g sat fat, 7g protein, 260mg calcium, 4g added sugars

So Delicious Dairy Free Coconut-milk yogurt alternative
Credit: So Delicious

SoDelicious Unsweetened Plain Coconutmilk Yogurt Alternative

WIth a consistency most similar to traditional yogurt, this smooth yogurt has a tropical vibe—try it topped with fruit and granola.

80 cal, 5g sat fat, <1g protein, 370mg calcium, 0g added sugars

Blue Diamond Almond Breeze Yogurt Alternative
Credit: Progressive Grocer

Almond Breeze Original Almondmilk Yogurt

If almond milk is your dairy-free drink of choice, you'll love it in yogurt form too. It has a silky mouthfeel and slightly sweet flavor.

110 cal, 0.5g sat fat, 3g protein, 190mg calcium, 0g added sugars

Follow Your Heart Plain Yogurt
Credit: Follow Your Heart

Follow Your Heart Plain Dairy-Free Yogurt

The texture of this mild-flavored coconut-milk-based yogurt is thick and creamy, like Greek yogurt, making it a great pick for frozen treats, smoothie bowls and dips.

150 cal, 11g sat fat, 1g protein, 516mg calcium, 1g added sugars

FORAGER PROJECT Organic Dairy-free Unsweetened Plain Cashewmilk Yogurt
Credit: Whole Foods

Forager Cashewmilk Yogurt Unsweetened Plain

The cashew base gives this pick a savory slant, making it perfect for culinary uses, such as adding creaminess to sauces, curries or soups.

110 cal, 1.5g sat fat, 3g protein, 26mg calcium, 0g added sugars

This article originally appeared in EatingWell Magazine, March 2021.