The Best Halloween Candy for Your Zodiac Sign, According to an Astrologer

Don’t get us wrong, we’re usually all about broccoli and kale—but come October, we love to indulge in our favorite Halloween candy (hey, it’s called balance!). Like us, you probably have a favorite treat you look forward to every Halloween, but why not switch it up this year by choosing a candy that’s perfect for your zodiac sign? We asked Kim Green, an astrologer from Valdosta, Georgia, to give us the scoop on which candy is best for your zodiac sign. Here’s what she had to say.

Aries, you are self-assured and independent, so you should opt for a Halloween candy that’s as unique and bold as you. Green says, “Aries is a fire sign, and Red Hots are perfect for their spicy temperament.” (Buy them: $13 for 12 boxes on Amazon)

“Taureans love food and luxury, and want to be pampered,” Green says. While caramel-filled dark chocolate truffles aren’t a Halloween staple, we wouldn’t put it past you to hand those out (and sneak a few for yourself). If you *had* to go the traditional Halloween candy route, Green says you’d opt for Snickers. She says, “Taurus is ruled by Venus, which is associated with chocolate.” (Buy them: $30 for a 3-pound bag on Amazon)

Green says, “The Sour Patch Kid motto applies to Gemini’s dualistic personality: First you’re sour, then you’re sweet.” And just like Sour Patch Kids, you’re lots of fun and people love to be around you. (Buy them: $11 for 240 mini bags on Amazon)

Related: The Best Cocktail for Your Zodiac Sign, According to an Astrologer

Milk Duds may not be the most exciting Halloween treat, but these milk chocolate candies are classic and comforting (just like you, Cancer!). Green says, “Cancers are warm and homey and motherly. Plus, Cancers are ruled by the moon, which also rules over milk.” (Buy them: $23 for a 2-pound bag on Amazon)

Let’s be honest, Leo, you always command attention in a room, just like popular Starburst candies. These rainbow-hued treats are bright, sweet and colorful, just like you. “Leo is the star of the show, and Starburst’s fruity and bold flavor shines,” Green says. (Buy them: $30 for a 5-pound bag on Amazon)

Smarties are the perfect Halloween candy for Virgos because your sign is associated with “intelligent, critical thinkers,” according to Green. She adds, “Most people think of Virgos as ‘Smarties.’” (Buy them: $22 for a 4-pound bag on Amazon)

Libra, you’re all about symmetry and harmony (in fact, your zodiac’s symbol is the scales). Green says, “Kit Kat bars have two textures, crunchy and smooth, which create balance, like Librans love.” Additionally, Green says, “Libra is ruled by Venus, which is associated with chocolate.” (Buy them: $17 for a 2-pound bag on Amazon)

Halloween is your holiday, Scorpio. It’s your season, so we couldn’t stick you with something basic like a lollipop. You need something as deep as you, so we chose Almond Joys (the layers of almonds, chocolate and coconut provide complex layers of flavor). Plus, Green says, “Coconut is ruled by Pluto, which is Scorpio’s planet.” (Buy them: $17 for a 2.5-pound bag on Amazon)

When it came to your sign, Green says it was a no-brainer: “Sagittarius is a fun sign with a personality that’s bright and colorful like Skittles.” No Halloween gathering is complete without a Sagittarius (or big bowl of Skittles) in the room. (Buy them: $17 for a 2.5-pound bag on Amazon)

Related: The Best Salad for Your Zodiac Sign, According to an Astrologer

Reese’s cups are the most popular Halloween candy in America, which appeals to your no-frills approach, Capricorn. You probably wouldn’t be into novelty candy or super out-there flavors. “Capricorns, in general, are traditional people who would appreciate the classic flavors of peanut butter and chocolate,” Green says. (Buy them: $18 for a 2-pound bag on Amazon)

We know that Pop Rocks aren’t a “traditional” holiday candy, but as Green says, “Aquarians like things that are out of the box and they like to be different.” Pop Rocks are a candy that’s as unique as you are. (Buy them: $19 for 24 packets on Amazon)

We couldn’t resist picking Swedish Fish for your Halloween candy, Pisces! Green says, “Pisces’ symbol is two fish swimming in opposite directions.” Plus, Pisces people generally have a very sweet disposition, like the sweet nature of these gummy candies. (Buy them: $14 for 240 mini packets on Amazon)