This dish was easy enough to make, but when I added the milk to the sherry, it curdled. When the meat was done, the sauce was still watery. Good flavor, except that it needed salt.
Chicken a la King
From EatingWell: EatingWell for a Healthy Heart Cookbook (2008)
There's no need to feel guilty over this classic creamy combination of chicken, peppers and mushrooms. Our version uses low-fat milk and flour for thickening to make it plenty rich without all the saturated fat. Serve over whole-wheat egg noodles.
11 Reviews for Chicken a la King
Easy and fun to prepare. Not enough "gravy"- I added almost twice as much liquid. Used canned mushrooms instead of fresh- I disagree with previous reviews regarding the sherry- I used the same amount that it called for & it tasted just fine.
I have to say, there are quite a few times when I read reviews on recipes and MOST of these reviewers do NOT follow the recipe correctly. Everyone has different tastes and recipes are only meant to GUIDE (if you notice, most of them direct to season to taste.) It is a mere blue-print, meant for any real cook to tweak and perfect to their own tastes. That being said, there are plenty of positive reviews that I WILL be trying this soon, exactly to recipe. Then I will try again with my own revisions. So far, I've found that the recipes on here are ALWAYS full of potential. They just need some adjusting here and there.
I agree with the previous commenter that there was way too much sherry. I followed the recipe but left out mushrooms. It was my first time trying pimentos. The result was a gray mess that tasted like the color it was. It had no initial flavor but a disgusting after taste. I'm a pretty good cook so I put this on the recipe.
Sorry to report this was a retch-worthy, unmitigated disaster. This recipe calls for 1 cup of dry sherry, which made it taste incredibly bitter. Was this a typo? After researching other recipes, I would only use maybe a tablespoon of sherry for flavor and I would increase the broth and/or milk that is used. Very disappointing.