This isn't even remotely accurate for me. I weigh about 250 pounds (down from 320 initially), which gives me 3000 calories. To lose 1 pound a week I should be eating 2500 and to lose 2 pounds a week I should be eating 2000? I don't think so. I burn at least 1800 calories a week at the gym and I gain weight when I eat more than 1700 calories a day. I wish I could lose weight with 2000 calories a day, lol.
07/02/2010 - 2:47am
Who came up with body weightx12 to maintain rule? Anyone following those guidelines would do serious, irreversible damage to their body eating that little.Even if they were bedridden! I'm a very, very small person I maintain on double the amount suggested here.
07/03/2010 - 11:03pm
I like the photos of the food to show an example of what a 1500 calorie day could look like. Some folks need a bit of help thinking up some meals, and this looks to be a well-balanced daily menu with a good assortment of items from the various food groups. However, I'm with other writers who suggest the weight times 12 to show calories to maintain weight is low. That would require me at 140 to need to drop below 1200 calories a day just to lose a pound a week, and losing 1.5 pounds or more would be out of the question with other factors not considered.
Of course, there certainly are those other factors, such as age, quality of foods consumed (junk food versus healthy), one's exercise program and daily activity level...it's certanly not a one-size-fits-all mathematical equation! I've heard the figure of 15 times one's weight as an estimate. But as another comment mentioned, that would be quite a high daily caloric intake for an extremely overweight person hoping to shed pounds.
One thought to consider: a healthy, well-planned eating plan of 1200 calories can be more nutritionally- satisfying than a 2,000+ calorie one comprised mostly of unwise choices (consider that one popular fast food "value meal" contains 1400 calories).
07/27/2010 - 7:41pm
I agree with "calories count'. I am just behind you...have lost 12 pounds in about 8 weeks, I weighed 168, now down to 156..need to lose another 20...and yes, though it's a bit slow, the body responds much better than with a crash diet that has you gain all the weight back in about 1 week!! I also am swimming 2 times a week (only for about 20-25 minutes) and walking for 30 minutes...I feel so much better, I know this is well worth the time!
07/28/2010 - 10:50am
Unless you are actually weighing your food and preparing it all your self you have no idea how much food you are eatting
08/10/2010 - 9:32am
the picture above is 300 calories not 1500!
12/12/2011 - 7:17pm
The picture actually is 1500 calories - the smoothie + yogurt/berries/(cereal?) mix is about 300 claories or so. If you think that all that food in the picture is worth 300 clories, you have a big problem on your hands.
12/16/2011 - 4:38pm
I use the Bodymedia arm band and use their website to enter in my food intake. I work out on an elliptical each day for an hour. (Resistance set to 3 usually and speed 55 RPMs) My armband usually indicates I burn 3000 calories a day and I keep to right at a caloric consumption of 2500 a day. Doing this from Jan 2011 to Jan 2012, I have lost 49 pounds. I started out at 245 (5'10" now 48 year old male). I just hit 195lbs today. I am not saying that you have to have an arm band like I do with the associated $6.95 monthly fee. (Though I do to keep on track) What you do need to do though is find out how much your body burns each day and then find someway to keep track of your calories each day. From what I have seen I would think the average person should burn between 2000 to 2500 calories by going about their daily activities without adding exercise. So limiting calories to 1500 to 1800 should produce slow but steady results. It took me 10 years to go from 170 to 245....not rocket science that it will take time to take it off. As a side not, my arm band indicates that while I am asleep I burn 1.4 calories per minute. So if I were to sleep all the time, my body would burn 2016 a day....my point is that would be a minimum burn...just sitting burns more.
01/06/2012 - 2:39am
According to your "how many calories I should be eating" chart, I should be eating 800 calories a day to burn 2 pounds a week. I think that is a very unhealthy number.
01/23/2012 - 3:51pm
The times 12 thing I think is really low. If I followed that I am suppose to eat only 1200 to maintain my weight and I eat close to 1500-2000 a day and maintain while working out.. Does that mean I am suppose to eat only 800 to lose a couple of pounds?