Subscribe to RSS

How to Choose: Apple Pie vs. Pumpkin Pie?

By Matthew Thompson, November 21, 2011 - 9:00am

  • Share

Q: “Which is healthier: apple or pumpkin pie?”

A: After a delicious Thanksgiving dinner, there comes a period of time in which I can’t even think about food. It’s a time for watching football or listening to a sibling snore on the couch, maybe knocking out a little dishwashing if I’m feeling ambitious. For a few hours, the house goes quiet as people enjoy the satisfaction of a post-meal stupor. Sooner or later, however, a pang of hunger finally comes back. And when it does: Pie.

Pie is point-after-touchdown of Thanksgiving Day. After enjoying one of the most delicious meals of the year, you get treated to an added bonus: a rich, sweet, flaky dessert. Talk about something to be thankful for!

But for the health-conscious, that extra treat can mean extra stress. It’s no fun to have to choose between potentially wrecking your diet and abstaining from part of the day’s celebration, especially when most people answer the question of whether they’d prefer apple pie or pumpkin with, “Both!”

Fortunately for those who’d like to indulge—but only a little!—EatingWell has a great comparison of which is healthier: apple or pumpkin pie. By comparing the nutritional impact of each (and each pie’s bonus nutritional pluses, as well!), we can help you make a decision about what makes sense for you during Thanksgiving’s final, delicious stage.

Countdown to Thanksgiving

For the two weeks leading up to Thanksgiving, we'll be answering your most pressing Thanksgiving cooking questions and offering up delicious Thanksgiving recipes, easy cooking advice and essential tips for making your Thanksgiving a meal to remember.

What’s your favorite holiday pie? Tell us what you think below.

TAGS: Matthew Thompson, Healthy Cooking Blog, Holidays, Thanksgiving, Thanksgiving Countdown

Matthew asks: What’s your favorite holiday pie?

Tell us what you think:

Get a full year of EatingWell magazine.
World Wide Web Health Award Winner Web Award Winner World Wide Web Health Award Winner Interactive Media Award Winner