Subscribe to RSS

New study says organic food is not healthier--is that really true?

By Nicci Micco, July 30, 2009 - 12:00pm

  • Share

Nicci asks: What, if anything, do you buy organic?


I have a chemical sensitivity and its very hard to live with! I try to buy organic but, as you suggested, I only buy organic apples and now, also strawberries. If I find myself eating a lot of one particular type of fruit or vegetable during a period of time, then I look for organic in that as well.

I check the list of the dirty dozen to remind myself from time to time and I avoid buying if there isn't an organic. There's always a selection, even if its limited.


10/01/2010 - 11:00pm

I believe that buying at least vegetarian/ no antibiotics or hormones is healthier and safer, particularly since we are having Salmonella issues here in the U.S. probably chicken as well, as I just began to purchase all natural Greenwise poultry.


09/26/2010 - 3:59pm

Yes, I can try to buy organic food.
In fact I don't to expect to be reacher with nutrition, but I expect to be less toxic than other food.
The organic food I would recommend it especially for children as it could help them to have less toxic
in their body.
Thank you EATING WELL for providing readers with such educational and helpful information,
hope may people are reading and it will helps them to choose healthier


08/19/2010 - 3:01pm

I purchase all my basic foods organic. These include:

grains: bread, cereal, rice, beans.

dairy: milk, cheese, butter, yogurt.

meat: beef (ground only as the others are too expensive) and chicken.

fruits/vegetables: lettuce, tomatoes (fresh and canned), berries, apples, and lemons.

spices: all dried spices and fresh garlic

Other: mustard, ketchup, and jam.

I purchase anything else organic that I can afford.

Exceptions: I eat local/in season vegetables, even if they are not organic,
and I do NOT purchase organic foods from Mexico or China.


08/19/2010 - 9:17am

Yes, I buy organic. I have a 4 year old daughter, and after doing a little research over food and health, I started shopping a little more in the organic section. At first I found organic food to be a bit expensive, but after reading articles that suggested organic food was healthier, contained more vitamins, and had the least amount of pesticides, I decided that spending a little extra money on organic food was a great investment. I find that in the society that we live in today, we tend to put more effort and spend more money on our clothing, cars, and handbags, than we do for our bodies. I also feel great knowing that I am supporting farmers that decided to take the risk to turn their farm land into an organic farm. Its very expensive and a lot of hard work for a farmer that grows organic produce. I have to say that I am satisfied with my conversion to organic. And also I find the taste of organic fruits and vegetables richer than commercial produce. Thank you EATING WELL for providing your readers with such educational and helpful information. It makes a difference.

Norisha Campbell


08/12/2010 - 8:59am

I try to buy organic chicken and eggs. I also stay away from soybean products unless they are organic. I was using soybean oil for all my frying needs and my health started to go down the drain. I love breaded and fried eggplant and ate it often but noticed getting weak and tired all the time. I took my vitamins as usual but still kept getting weaker. It wasn't till I looked on the bottle of my vegetable oil and all it said was soybean oil. I was raised on a farm and know what it takes to keep soybeans bug free. I eliminated that oil from my cooking and my strength and energy is coming back. I still eat my eggplant but a different oil. My red eyes cleared up too and I don't drink alcohol. I will only eat corn that has a silkworm in it this way I know it is not GMO. Some can say any lie they choose but I have children who get ill on GMO corn. I can't digest it. I bought a couple hybrid tomato plants last year and they hardly grew plus the plant and veggies got some kind of fungus and rotted next to my unhybrid plants. It was amazing. My friends and they are many know that we are being poisond and we may eat less but it is organic for us as much as possible. Watch Food Inc. for a real eye opener.


04/28/2010 - 10:21pm

To Ms. Micco,

A profitably informative article but with the usual anomalies among news writing, to wit:
The London School claims no difference between organic and non-organically produced food with your subsequent conclusion "End of story? I don't think so" which implies you disagree and, sure enough, the remainder of the article supports your skepticism with three studies claiming a difference in favor of organically produced food. YET, you, THEN say "The jury is still out." Now, you're equivocating.

Plus, the "Organic Center" is not identified beyond this generic name.

Laurence Alter


03/25/2010 - 6:11am

When can we consumer have the right to know which product is from GMO or not? I do not mind to buy some conventional products if they are not from GMO. When is the FDA willing to put labels on what products that is from GMO and what products is not from GMO?


03/20/2010 - 2:14pm

O.K., This is interesting stuff. I am looking into eating more of a all natural/ organic diet and we are in the middle of switching our cattle opertion to an all natural forage finished type of operation. I can see both sides of this story pretty clearly I feel from the pesticides to the comments of GMO's. I am not only inviolved in some production Agriculture I sell seed to farmers for a living and understand the necessity and value of raising a quality crop to feed a growing world population that is becoming less self sustaining everyday. One thought on the nutritive level of a organic vs. a conventional is this; a conventional peice of produce is nearly always harvested before it is fully mature where as most organic is harvested when it is more fully mature, what makes the organic have more oppritunity to be a healthier more nutritient dense peice of produce is that being harvested later in the maturing process lets more photosynthesis occur and that allows more energy to produce more nutients , flavor, sugars, etc.... most of the good things in produce come at late in the maturing process . Now on the GMO comment from another blogger. One thing you need to realize is that most of what you are seeing in terms of "mutant" plants is not the result of the traits or fertilzers or pesticdes (these things help raise a crop and help it reach its genetic potential) it is because of the GENETICS of the plants, these plants are living creatures and through breeding techniques plant breeders can do some amazing things with germ plasm and cross pollination to have what you would think is a freak but in reality it is a plant that has been bred to have those certain charectaristics.It would be like taking two great athletes and they had children, those kids would probably be great athletes vs. a set of parents that were average, you may think that those other kids were freaks but it is genetics and inherited traits that allow them to be great.


03/20/2010 - 10:48am

I work in the Ag Indusry, to be more specific I sell seed to farmers but I have really been looking into eating a diet with more all natural and organic in it. The conclusions I come up with is that so much of the conventional produce is harvested so early it cannot aqiure enough photosynthesis to finishing it's developement of nutrients or flavor or sugars. These are obtained in the last part of a crop maturing (very late). Many of the organics are harvested at a more mature stage so they would have those things missing from a conventional counterpart. Also I have noticed that in some convantionally grown crops thed application of certain pesticides can set back growth so maybe that has something to do with nutrient developement. Also are these studies comparing produce raised from the same area, harvested on the same day, etc.... I have seen so much skewed data in my career because these things that some people think aren't significant really are, and make huge differences in results. Another thing we must keep in mind is that we will always have to have pesticides and commercial fertilizers and all those things associated with modern day Agriculture, as the world populations continue to grow and people continue to become less self sustaining everyday we need to feed them and those products will play a large role in doing so.


03/20/2010 - 10:11am

Get a full year of EatingWell magazine.
World Wide Web Health Award Winner Web Award Winner World Wide Web Health Award Winner Interactive Media Award Winner